The Best Grille Assembly Brands for Your Next Project

Lisa Conant, Automotive Features Reviewer at CarParts.com

Reviewed by

Lisa Conant, Automotive Content Specialist

Automotive Features Reviewer at CarParts.com

Written by CarParts.com Research Team - Updated on September 8th, 2025

Reading Time: 5 minutes

Summary

  • Replace a damaged grille quickly to protect your ride's cooling components and preserve your car's good looks.

  • JC Whitney®, Replacement, ReplaceXL, Mopar®, and Key Parts® are some of the brands you should consider when shopping for a replacement grille.

  • When choosing between brands, choose one that stands out for its broad selection, clear fitment details, and value-focused pricing.

Modern cars make grille design more functional than ever, with active shutters, integrated cameras, and precise fitment requirements. That means you can’t just throw on something that “kinda fits.” You need a part built to match the factory shape, with the right mounts for trim, emblems, and sensors. Good news is, there are plenty of aftermarket options that fit like stock parts without the dealership markup.

Aftermarket replacement grille assemblies are built to match factory quality but cost less, so you can save money without sacrificing durability. You can check out a wide selection of solid options at CarParts.com and find one that fits your vehicle right away.

The 6 Best Grille Assembly Brands

Here are the five brands to check out if you want a grille assembly that’s easy to install, looks good, and won’t take weeks to arrive:

  • JC Whitney®
  • Replacement
  • ReplaceXL
  • Mopar®
  • Key Parts®

Note: Prices may vary depending on the part manufacturer, the vehicle’s year, make, model, and other factors.

JC Whitney®

JC Whitney® has been around since 1915, and while the name used to be synonymous with massive paper catalogs, they’ve taken their inventory online. Their lineup includes budget-friendly replacements, continuing their legacy of offering good value to drivers. This brand also carries CAPA-certified collision repair parts, and even kits with header panels included.

JC Whitney® grille assemblies span everything from budget daily-driver replacements to CAPA-certified bundles that include header panels.

Features

Prices Range: $8 to $600

Available finishes: Textured black, chrome, paint-to-match, with CAPA-certified options 

Direct-fit designs for easier installation and proper sensor/trim transfer

Covers a wide range of makes and models

Our Score: 10/10

Replacement

Replacement is a go-to brand for affordable collision parts. The focus here is on matching OE specs for fit and finish so the grille lines up with your bumper, headlights, and any integrated active shutter system. Most parts come with a one-year, unlimited-mileage warranty.

Replacement grille assemblies follow OE specifications to ensure snug alignment with bumper covers, headlights, and active shutters.

Features

Prices Range: $6 to $1,800

Multiple finishes: Black, chrome, and paint-to-match

Styles: Mesh, cross-bar, or honeycomb styles

Some SKUs include fillers or trim pieces

Direct-fit construction for correct alignment

One-year, unlimited-mileage warranty

Our Score: 9/10

ReplaceXL

ReplaceXL is built for buyers who want the lowest possible price without giving up fit. It’s positioned as the budget-friendly branch of this catalog but still offers CAPA-certified parts for certain applications—handy if you’re working with insurance repairs.

ReplaceXL offers vehicle owners plenty of options for affordable yet high-quality grille replacements for a wide variety of models.

Features

Price Range: $8 for basic components to $2,230 for extensive kits

CAPA-certified versions available

Fits a broad mix of domestic and import models.

One-year, unlimited-mileage warranty

Our Score: 9/10

Mopar®

If you drive a Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep, Ram, or Fiat and want the exact same grille the factory installed, Mopar® is the source. These parts are built by (or for) the automaker, so you’re getting the correct materials, hardware, and emblem provisions—often at a higher cost than aftermarket options.

Mopar® grille assemblies are engineered for exact fit and often include model-specific hardware or emblem provisions.

Features

Prices Range: $13 to $1,900

Genuine OEM construction for perfect fit and factory-correct styling

Covered by Mopar’s limited parts warranty

Standard and active shutter grille assemblies available

Our Score: 9/10

Key Parts®

Key Parts® has been a big name in the restoration scene for decades, especially for classic trucks and SUVs. They specialize in OE-style reproductions that bring back the factory look, right down to emblem cutouts and original contours. They’re also an officially licensed Mopar® restoration supplier for select Jeep models.

Key Parts®  focuses on OE-style reproductions with correct contours and emblem provision for factory-look builds.

Features

Prices Range: $150 to $1,040.

OE-style reproduction grilles for older trucks and SUVs

Many options come with emblem cutouts for Chevrolet, GMC, and others

Large restoration catalog with thousands of related body parts.

Clear fitment and material details 

Our Score: 8/10

Our Recommendation

If you want the easiest buying experience and a grille that fits without drama, JC Whitney® is hard to beat. The prices are fair, the selection is huge, and you can even find CAPA-certified parts or bundled kits if you’re tackling a bigger repair. The clear product descriptions and OE reference numbers take the guesswork out of the process, which means you’ll only have to order once.

What to Look for in a Replacement Grille Assembly

1) Fitment Matters

Match the grille to your vehicle’s exact year, make, model, and trim—and don’t forget options like active shutters, parking sensors, and cameras. Even a slight mismatch can cause mounting issues or leave gaps you can’t hide. VIN lookup tools and online fitment checkers are worth using before you spend a dime.

2) Materials and Finish

ABS plastic and composites are common on modern cars, while older models might use metal. Most grilles come in finish options like textured black, paint-to-match, or chrome. If you’re working with an insurance job, CAPA-certified parts are worth considering since they meet industry quality benchmarks.

3) What’s in the Box

Some assemblies are just the grille shell. Others include header panels, fillers, or emblem mounts. Buying a complete kit can save time and reduce the chance you’ll be stuck mid-install waiting for another part to arrive.

4) Warranty and Return Policies

Brands often back their grilles with a one-year, unlimited-mileage warranty. Some even offer a Lifetime Replacement Guarantee on certain parts. Read the warranty coverage thoroughly before finalizing your purchase.

5) Price vs. OEM Branding

Aftermarket grilles usually cost less than OEM but still match factory fit. If you want exact branding or you’re restoring a newer vehicle, OEM options like Mopar give you the real deal, but at a higher price. For older vehicles, reproduction brands like Key Parts can get you the authentic look without tracking down rare factory pieces.

Any information provided on this Website is for informational purposes only and is not intended to replace consultation with a professional mechanic. The accuracy and timeliness of the information may change from the time of publication.

Share
Published by
CarParts.com Research Team and Lisa Conant, Automotive Content Specialist