Hi Nicki, I'm glad to assist you. Both are basically the same bumper and the main difference is the other one is with CAPA certification (with Q at the end of the part number) for quality assurance matching and complying to the OEM quality standards. The affordable one worth $101.99 is with an ongoing promo sale price drop offer. Click the link below to order today and grab our ongoing labor day best deal by entering coupon code LABORDAY/LABORDAY5 on the coupon code box before you checkout. I hope this helps. Happy shopping. https://www.carparts.com/details/Subaru/Forester/Replacement/Bumper_Cover/2012/X/4_Cyl_2-dot-5L/REPS010313PQ.html?can=CPJE1043

Hi Sandra, These Bumper Covers are made of shape-memory plastic and will eventually go back to their original shape after you put them under the sun for at least 2 hours. If there is no sun, you can apply heat on the affected area with a heat gun (just make sure not to over-heat and melt the material). You can also boil a pot of water and pour it over the dented area on your bumper. Reach behind the bumper and pop the dent out. You might also need to take the bumper off if the dent can't be reached. Finally, pour a pot of cold water onto the bumper to cool and fix the plastic area.