Need car parts? Select your vehicle
Reading Time: 5 minutes
Summary
  • The Mini Cooper’s resale value is pretty good, going for 47% of its original price while it still has 58% of its useful lifespan.
  • The Mini Cooper received a 3.0 out of 5.0 reliability rating from RepairPal, but newer models reportedly have improved reliability.
  • The Cooper’s 2015-2019 model years are considered the most reliable.
  • Some of the top Mini Cooper problems include clutch failure, electric door lock malfunction, a failed power steering pump, transmission failure, and water pooling on the floorboard.

When talking about legendary cars, who would forget the Mini Cooper? Although subcompacts have decreased in popularity in recent years, the Mini remains a sought-after vehicle, thanks to its unique design and go-kart-inspired handling. Its resale value is also good, especially the 2016 model year. People can buy it with only around 47% of its original price while it still has 58% of its useful lifespan, according to CarEdge.com.

Is the Mini Cooper Reliable?

The Mini Cooper received average scores on major reliability ratings. RepairPal gives it a 3.0 out of 5.0, giving it the last spot out of 21 subcompact cars in its segment. The score is based on the reported cost, severity, and frequency of car repair. The average annual repair cost for a Mini Cooper can reach up to $846, which is higher than the ride’s average ownership costs.

Newer Mini Cooper models are improving in terms of reliability. In fact, J.D. Power named the Mini Cooper the most dependable car in 2019 and gave the 2020 model a top spot in its vehicle dependability list. This is a major development, as J.D. Power ranked it 28th out of the 32 cars in its segment four years prior.

See also  AWD, RWD, or FWD: What's the Best Car for Driving in the Snow?

What’s the Best Year for the Mini Cooper?

Red Mini Cooper S with White Racing Stripe Parked
The Cooper’s 2015-2019 model years are the best when it comes to reliability, according to Consumer Reports.

The Cooper’s 2015-2019 model years are the best when it comes to reliability, according to Consumer Reports. The Mini Cooper’s reliability ratings have significantly improved since the brand’s major redesign in 2014. So much so that the car received above-average scores from Consumer Reports for model years 2015 onwards.

Top Mini Cooper Problems

Whether you’re planning to buy a Mini Cooper or you already own one, you must be aware of the issues that it may develop as it gains mileage. Here are the Mini Cooper’s common problems across model years:

Clutch Failure

Issues with the clutch are common among first- and second-generation Mini Coopers. Many owners of 2002-2016 models have complained that their clutch failed ahead of its time, which affected their manual transmission. Most of them had to replace their clutch to solve the issue.

Electric Door Lock Malfunction

Another issue that has affected several model years (2004-2005, 2008-2011, and 2013-2016 Mini Coopers) has to do with a faulty electric door lock. Owners of the affected units have reported problems locking and unlocking their doors, making it difficult to enter or exit their Mini Cooper. The issue seemed to occur around the time their cars racked up 94,000 miles. Some have been able to resolve the problem by replacing the malfunctioning door lock.

Power Steering Pump Failure

Many owners of 2002-2007 and 2012 Mini Cooper models have reported issues with their power steering pump. The National Highway Traffic Administration (NHTSA) issued a recall in 2015 for 2002-2005 Mini Cooper models to address this problem. Most of the vehicles came with an electro-hydraulic power steering system that was prone to temporary or permanent failure.

See also  Mini Cooper Convertible Could Be Bowing Out Soon

In most cases, mechanics found that the pump failed due to a bad cooling fan, so simply replacing the pump wouldn’t solve the issue. If your Mini’s power steering pump is malfunctioning, take it to a technician for a thorough inspection.

Transmission Failure

Transmission failure may not be as widely reported as some of the other issues in this article, but it’s among the problems that have the highest repair cost. A lawsuit was even filed accusing BMW of not disclosing that various Mini Cooper models had transmission defects. It covered the 2002-2006 Mini Hardtop and the 2005-2008 Mini Convertible. BMW denied the allegations but agreed to provide refunds under a class action settlement.

Water Pooling on Floorboard

MINI Cooper S 3 door interior
Many Mini Cooper drivers also complained of water pooling on the floorboard, which can damage the cable harness under the vehicle. Image source: MINI USA Newsroom.

Many Mini Cooper drivers also complained of water pooling on the floorboard, which can damage the cable harness under their vehicle. Most of them had to replace their cable harness to ensure that signal transmission is facilitated efficiently. However, one owner had to repair and replace the whole electrical system due to water damage, which cost at least $4,000.

Water Pump and Thermostat Housing Leaks

Leaks due to a compromised water pump and thermostat housing are also common among first- and second-generation Mini Coopers. The thermostat housing on second-gen Mini Coopers is made of plastic, so it’s prone to damage. If you own or are planning to buy these models, make sure to do preventive maintenance and replace your thermostat housing to prevent costly damage due to leaks.

Radiator Support Issues

Mini Coopers are also susceptible to radiator support issues because of their low ground clearance. Their front radiator support is typically made of plastic to reduce their weight. But this also made it vulnerable to impact, which means curbs and large bumps may damage the Mini’s radiator support and coolant hose. Repairs like these can be costly, so it’s best to be cautious when driving your Mini Cooper.

See also  New Mini Electric Draws "Keen Interest" from Customers

Variable Valve Timing (VVT) Problems

Inadequate oil in the Mini Cooper’s VVT system can lead to increased friction, which can result in symptoms like engine idling and reduced gas mileage. Repairs for this system can be costly, but you can prevent them by following your vehicle’s oil change schedule.

If you own or plan to get a Mini Cooper, it’s a good idea to research common problems that may arise as it racks up mileage. By knowing which parts may require repairs or replacement, you can stay one step ahead and maximize your Mini Cooper’s service life.

Where to Get Top-Notch Parts for Your Mini Cooper

Like any other vehicle on the market, your Mini Cooper’s parts can wear out or become faulty as it gains mileage. Luckily, CarParts.com is your one-stop shop for Mini Cooper parts sourced from the best brands in the industry.

To start shopping, simply input your Mini Cooper’s exact details into our easy-to-use vehicle selector. Don’t forget to include the model year so that our system can present you with parts compatible with your ride.

Need your parts as soon as possible? We have warehouses strategically located across the country to ensure fast and efficient shipping. We also have a 24/7 customer service hotline in case you have questions about your order.

Check out our selection of Mini Cooper parts now, and order what you need today!

About The Author
Written By Automotive and Tech Writers

The CarParts.com Research Team is composed of experienced automotive and tech writers working with (ASE)-certified automobile technicians and automotive journalists to bring up-to-date, helpful information to car owners in the US. Guided by CarParts.com's thorough editorial process, our team strives to produce guides and resources DIYers and casual car owners can trust.

Any information provided on this Website is for informational purposes only and is not intended to replace consultation with a professional mechanic. The accuracy and timeliness of the information may change from the time of publication.

File Under : Vehicle Reliability Tagged With :
Powerstop
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

View all Questions & Answers

expand_more
CarParts.com Answers BE PART OF OUR COMMUNITY: Share your knowledge & help fellow drivers Join Now