If your bumper cover‘s cracked, dinged, or MIA after a fender-bender, replacing it isn’t just about looks. That panel plays defense for more expensive parts underneath, like your grille, headlights, and radiator. Drive around without one and you’re not just risking more damage, you’re dragging down your car’s value, too.
And if you’re stuck with a high deductible or your claim is dragging on, you don’t have to wait around or shell out at the dealership. Aftermarket bumper covers often look and fit just like the originals, but without the inflated price tag. It’s a quick way to get your car back in shape without spending a fortune.
Aftermarket replacement bumper covers are as durable as their OE counterparts but they are more affordable, which means you can get the same quality while saving money at the same time. Check out high-quality replacement bumper covers at CarParts.com today.
The 6 Best Bumper Cover Brands
If you’re digging through pages of replacement bumper covers, these six brands rise to the top. Whether you’re looking for a deal, a direct fit, or something that’s just hard to find, they’ve got you covered.
- JC Whitney
- Replacement
- ReplaceXL
- Sherman
- Mopar
- Crown
JC Whitney
JC Whitney has been around since 1915 and is one of the most recognizable names in the U.S. aftermarket scene. They’ve built their reputation on solid, wallet-friendly parts that fit right and hold up. One of the brand’s standout perks? Their bumper kits often come bundled with other parts like absorbers and lights, which can save you a trip (and extra cost).
Key Features:
- Price range: ~$93.99 to $616.99, depending on vehicle and kit
- Sold individually or in bundles (2- or 3-piece kits with extras)
- Locations covered: front, rear, upper, lower, center
- Finishes: Primed, Textured, OE-style
- Assembly types: With or without brackets/sensor cutouts
- Fit: Direct Fit, OE Replacement
Our Score: 10/10
Replacement
Replacement is CarParts.com’s in-house brand, and it’s built to match OE fit and feel without the markup. It’s trusted by folks looking for affordable exterior parts that don’t cut corners. You can even find CAPA-certified options here, which are often required for insurance-covered repairs.
Key Features:
- Price range: ~$56.19 to $208.49 (often 50% to 85% off dealership prices)
- CAPA-certified choices available
- Front, rear, upper, center fitment for all body types
- Sold solo or in multi-piece kits
- Usually primed and ready to paint
- Backed by 1-year unlimited-mileage warranty
Our Score: 10/10
ReplaceXL
ReplaceXL sits in the sweet spot between budget and premium. It’s a favorite among DIYers and pros who want reliable fit without spending big. The brand also offers CAPA-certified options, which makes it a solid pick for more serious repair work.
Key Features:
- Price range: ~$92.40 to $201.27
- Front and rear coverage in textured or primed finishes
- CAPA Certified options available
- Direct Fit with sensor/fog light provisions where needed
- Reviewed well for fit and installation ease
Our Score: 9/10
Sherman
Sherman has a long-standing presence in the collision repair space, especially when it comes to body panels and sheet metal. Many body shops trust Sherman parts to arrive ready for paint and install. They’re not always the cheapest, but they tend to be hassle-free.
Key Features:
- Price varies depending on model and certification
- Great fitment for older or niche vehicles
- Finishes include primed, textured, OE-match
- Often used in pro repair shops
- Compatible with sensors, fog lights, and tow hooks
Our Score: 9/10
Mopar
Mopar is the go-to brand for Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep, and Ram owners. These aren’t aftermarket parts in the usual sense—they’re actual OEM parts sold outside the dealership network. That means you’re getting the real thing, just not paying full dealer markup.
Key Features:
- Built for Chrysler, Dodge, Jeep, and Ram vehicles
- Factory-level fit and materials
- Usually comes primed and ready for paint
- Includes sensor/light cutouts when needed
- OEM warranty coverage
Our Score: 8.5/10
Crown
Crown Automotive is all about Jeep parts. Their catalog is massive, and their bumper covers are tough enough for daily driving and weekend off-roading. For Jeep folks who don’t want to blow their budget, Crown hits a nice balance between rugged and affordable.
Key Features:
- Built specifically for Jeep models like the Cherokee and Wrangler
- Made to handle trail and utility use
- OE-style looks with optional sensor/fog light cutouts
- Offered in textured and primed finishes
- Generally cheaper than OEM options
Our Score: 8/10
Our Recommendation
JC Whitney gets the top pick. The brand stands out for its wide range of vehicle coverage, package deals that include multiple components, and a reputation for getting the fit right. It’s also one of the better bangs for your buck, especially if you need more than just the cover. Whether you’re patching up after a collision or restoring a project car, JC Whitney is a smart, cost-conscious choice.
What to Consider When Looking for a Replacement Bumper Cover
1. Fitment and Application
You can’t eyeball bumper covers; they’re specific down to year, trim, and sometimes even production date. Before buying, confirm that the part fits your exact vehicle. A VIN-based lookup tool can take out the guesswork.
2. Material and Durability
Most bumper covers are made from ABS plastic or polypropylene, which strike a good balance between flexibility and toughness. If you live in a snowy area or drive off-road, consider reinforced versions or textured finishes that can take a little more abuse.
3. Color and Finish Options
Primed bumper covers need painting, while textured or paint-to-match versions may be usable right out of the box. Trucks and SUVs often lean toward textured finishes, while daily drivers usually go with primed.
4. Assembly Type
Some covers are bare panels. Others come as kits with reinforcements, brackets, or lights. If you’re tackling the job yourself, getting a full kit can save time and avoid missing parts.
5. Certification and Warranty
CAPA-certified parts are third-party tested to meet OE standards, which is especially useful for insurance claims. Brands like Replacement and ReplaceXL often offer these. Also, look for a decent warranty; most reputable brands back their bumper covers with at least one year of coverage.
Browse CarParts.com for a full selection of bumper covers, and get your ride back to looking right without overspending.
Keep Reading: Related Posts
Any information provided on this Website is for informational purposes only and is not intended to replace consultation with a professional mechanic. The accuracy and timeliness of the information may change from the time of publication.
