The Best Step Bumper Brands: Tough Replacements That Fit

When your step bumper takes a hit or starts to rust, it can jeopardize your vehicle’s hitch stability, safety, and trailer control. Don’t hesitate. Replace a faulty step bumper right away.

Buying OEM parts often means longer wait times and higher costs. Don’t worry. Many aftermarket step bumpers match factory strength and fit while offering more finishes, quicker availability, and more affordable pricing.

Aftermarket replacement step bumpers are as durable as their OE counterparts but they’re more affordable, which means you can get the same quality while saving money. Check out high-quality replacement step bumpers at CarParts.com today.

The 5 Best Step Bumper Brands

These five brands delivering good fitment, finish, and replacement options right when you need them:

• JC Whitney
• Replacement
• ReplaceXL
• FEY
• Mopar

JC Whitney

JC Whitney started in 1915 as a Chicago scrap metal yard and has since grown into a catalog and parts powerhouse. Today, under CarParts.com’s banner, it still delivers a massive range of parts—especially for older, retired models or vehicles with niche accessories. If your truck dates back decades or your parts list glitters with vintage options, it’s likely JC Whitney has it.

Key Features

• Covers rare and legacy truck models with hard-to-find bumpers
• Pricing ranges widely depending on part rarity and finish
• Offers both painted and chrome options, usually as individual components
• Inventory varies based on catalog legacy and archival stock
• Fitment may require double-checking for older trucks

Our Score: 10/10

Replacement

Replacement is the go-to label if you want a basic, direct-fit step bumper at a fair price. Its models cover standard late-model applications, and they keep it simple—no bells and whistles, just a bumper that looks and bolts on like your factory unit.

Key Features

• Smooth integration for common truck models
• Clean finishes, often powder-coated or plain steel
• Pricing sits squarely in the mid-tier range
• Listings often note whether mounting are brackets included or not
• Minimal surprises during install

Our Score: 8.2/10

ReplaceXL

ReplaceXL focuses on budget-friendly OE-quality bumpers, complete with a generous warranty and corrosion protection. It boasts salt-spray testing and unlimited mileage coverage. That makes it a smart pick if you want coverage far beyond just a few seasons.

Key Features

• Built using the same footprint as OE bumpers
• Typically carry 1-year unlimited mileage warranties
• Salt-spray testing suggests strong rust resistance
• Options often include face bar + pads, chrome or painted finishes
• Fast shipping warehouses keep wait time short

Our Score: 8.3/10

FEY

Part of Westin’s lineup, FEY makes bumpers that combine style and function, like the DiamondStep and Surestep lines. These bumpers often use heavy-gauge steel, offer over 8,000 lbs towing capacity, and deliver a classic ribbed look. They’re also backed with a solid three-year warranty.

Key Features

• 14-gauge steel construction with ribbed design for grip 
• Tongue weights up to 800 lbs; towing up to 8,000 lbs
• Available in chrome, black, and silver finishes
• Three-year warranty and broad availability via Westin network 
• True OE-compatible options and stylish premium upgrades

Our Score: 9/10

Mopar

If you drive a Chrysler, Dodge, Ram, or Jeep, Mopar should be your No. 1 stop. These bumpers are designed to fit the heritage models you rely on daily. While fewer styles exist than aftermarket labels, you get OEM specs and backing—perfect for keeping that dealership feel and compliance intact.

Key Features

• Genuine factory replacement for FCA vehicles
• Finishes and design match original fitment exactly
• Pricier, but fit and finish align with brand standards
• Fewer aesthetic options, but ultra-precise fit
• Ideal for warranty-sensitive or collector-standard vehicles

Our Score: 8.7/10

Our Recommendation

If you want the best mix of coverage, availability, and practical options for a wide range of trucks, JC Whitney is the clear choice. With a century-long history in the parts business, it remains a strong source for both common and hard-to-find step bumpers—especially for older or discontinued models. Whether you’re restoring a vintage pickup, replacing a worn factory bumper, or upgrading to a fresh finish, JC Whitney’s broad catalog and fair pricing make it a dependable first stop.

Looking for a Replacement Step Bumper?

Here’s what to consider:

Application

 Your bumper has to match your truck’s exact setup—pad provision, mounting brackets, towing capacity, and finish. JC Whitney offers one of the widest selections, covering both modern and older trucks, which makes it easier to match unusual or legacy fitments. Brands like Mopar work best for factory-accurate replacements, while FEY, Replacement, and ReplaceXL cover more style and budget choices.

Quality & Reliability

 If you need something that lasts, especially for towing or heavy-duty work, look at brands with strong construction and proven track records. JC Whitney’s variety means you can choose from OEM-equivalent options to upgraded designs. FEY focuses on heavy-gauge steel and towing capability, while ReplaceXL emphasizes rust resistance.

Cost vs. Long-Term Value

JC Whitney’s pricing runs from budget-friendly to premium, depending on the model and finish, making it flexible for different budgets. Replacement offers some of the most affordable options, while ReplaceXL and FEY sit in the middle-to-higher tier for extra durability or style. Meanwhile Mopar offers genuine OEM parts.

Installation Components

Some bumpers ship bare, while others arrive with pads, brackets, and hardware. JC Whitney carries both setups, so you can pick what fits your needs. ReplaceXL and FEY tend to include more hardware in the box, while Replacement and Mopar vary by part.

Warranty & Backing

JC Whitney sources bumpers from suppliers with dependable coverage, while FEY offers a three-year warranty, ReplaceXL provides unlimited mileage coverage, and Mopar sticks to factory warranty terms. Replacement usually covers manufacturing defects but may not match the coverage length of other brands.If you need a replacement step bumper, CarParts.com has you covered. We offer fast shipping, easy-fit tools, and prices that help you get it done today—not next week. What are you waiting for? Get your replacement step bumper here at CarParts.com today!