The part was just what I needed and it fit well... Or at least would have fit well, had it been not been shipped with such lack of care.
The box arrived looking in real terrible shape, and the fender trim ordered was, unsurprisingly, bent on both sides (It's worth noting that it's only form of packaging material was one strip of air pillow bubble wrap. Not quite the most protective or ideal form of packaging for something like this). Luckily, it's quite the malleable metal, so with little effort, I was able to bend it back. Except for the fact that I had to fiddle with it for nearly half an hour to get it to fit just right before I committed to putting in the screws.
All in all, everything worked out fine. I got it installed, and it does look good, don't get me wrong. It was just a bit of an inconvenience for what could have been a quick and satisfying job.