Let’s face it: fender damage is almost a rite of passage. A stray shopping cart, a low-speed run-in with a curb, or highway gravel can leave your ride looking rough. It’s not just cosmetic as a dented fender can invite rust and moisture where you really don’t want it.
Factory replacements are pricey and slow to arrive. Aftermarket ones cost less, arrive quicker, and protect your car just as well. The tricky part? Figuring out which fender brands are actually worth it.
We’ve rounded up the best fender brands that deliver solid build quality and value without cutting corners.
6 Fender Brands That Get It Right
Whether you’re fixing a commuter car or breathing new life into a classic, these fender brands offer the goods:
- JC Whitney®
- Replacement
- ReplaceXL
- Key Parts®
- Brothers Trucks®
- Crown®
Best Overall Pick: JC Whitney®
JC Whitney® has been in the game since 1915. If you’re driving a truck or SUV, they probably have a fender that fits. Their parts adhere to factory specifications, and most include a lifetime warranty that’s hard to beat.
Features:
Prices range from $149.99 to $1,205.99
Fits front driver & passenger sides
Some CAPA-certified options
Arrives primed and paint-ready
Sold as OE replacements
Lifetime limited warranty
Our Score: 10/10
Best for Budget-Conscious Drivers: Replacement
No-frills, no fluff. Replacement makes fenders that fit well and don’t drain your bank account. They’ve got parts for nearly every car type—from vintage rides to today’s models.
Features:
Prices range from $27.99 to $2,446.28
Covers all major fender positions
Mostly steel, some plastic
Primed finish, with a few chrome options
Sold individually or in pairs
Works with modern and older vehicles
Our Score: 9.5/10
Great for DIYers: ReplaceXL
ReplaceXL hits the mark with OE-style fenders that are easy to install. They focus on precision so you’re not stuck drilling or adjusting during the install.
Features:
Prices range from $20 to $1,200
Fits front driver & passenger sides
Primed and paintable
Designed for quick installs
Our Score: 9/10
Top Pick for Classic Trucks: Key Parts®
Restoring a vintage ride? Key Parts® is made for you. They recreate the original look with updated materials, especially for old-school Ford and Chevy trucks.
Features:
Prices range from $30 to $1,010
Includes front fenders, quarters, inner panels
Primed steel
OE-style fit for classics
Warranty varies by item
Our Score: 8.5/10
Best for Vintage GM Fans: Brothers Trucks®
Built by people who love old trucks. Brothers Trucks® specializes in GM classics and makes sure the parts look right once installed—period-correct down to the details.
Features:
Prices range from $57.45 to $649.95
OE-style fit
Steel with pre-drilled holes
Lifetime warranty
Our Score: 9/10
Best for Jeep Owners: Crown®
Crown® Automotive knows Jeeps. If you’re replacing a Jeep fender, chances are they’ve got it. Their products are built to match original specs without the dealership markup.
Features:
Prices range from $120 to $600
Fits front driver & passenger sides
Steel with black OE-style primer
Jeep-specific fitment
Meets OEM standards
Our Score: 8.5/10
Editor’s Pick: JC Whitney®
If you want a fender that checks all the boxes, go with JC Whitney®. They offer OE-spec builds, CAPA-certified options, and solid warranties. You’ll get peace of mind without spending a fortune.
Quick Tips Before You Buy
1. Fitment
Always double-check your vehicle’s year, make, model, and trim. A close-enough match can still cause gaps or misalignment.
2. Materials
Most fenders are steel, but you’ll find plastic or composite ones too. Steel’s tougher; plastic’s lighter. If you’re painting, pick one that’s already primed.
3. Price vs. Details
Cheaper parts may skimp on things like coating or pre-drilled holes. Make sure you’re getting the features you need, not just a low number.
4. Installation
Doing it yourself? Look for bolt-on fenders with pre-cut holes. The closer it is to factory design, the easier the job.
5. Warranty & Certification
CAPA-certified parts are tested to match factory quality. And if a brand offers a lifetime warranty, that’s a big plus.
Want to browse options? CarParts.com has a huge selection of fenders that ship fast and fit right. Take a look and see what works for your ride.
Keep Reading: Related Posts
Any information provided on this Website is for informational purposes only and is not intended to replace consultation with a professional mechanic. The accuracy and timeliness of the information may change from the time of publication.
